• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Momcrieff

Recipes | Gardening | DIY | My 1920's house

  • About Me
    • Contact me
  • My 100 year old home
  • Recipes
    • Four Ingredients or Less!
    • Appetizers
    • Main Dish
    • Soups
    • Baked Items
    • Desserts & Treats
  • Gardening
    • Spring Gardening
    • Fall Gardening
    • Gardening And Landscaping
    • Planters / Containers
    • Misc. & Chores
  • DIY
    • DIY
    • Valentine's Day
    • Spring
    • Fabulous Fall!
    • Christmas & Winter
  • Misc.
    • Vacations
      • Family Vacation
    • Home Ownership
  • Nav Social Menu

  • Nav Social Menu

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • RSS
    • Twitter
menu icon
go to homepage
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • my-1923-house
  • Easy Recipes
  • Gardening
  • DIY
  • About Me
  • Subscribe
  • Yum
  • ×

    Home » my-1923-house

    Hardwood floor refinishing in my vintage (100-year-old) home.

    Published: Feb 9, 2020 · Modified: Jan 14, 2023 by Susan Moncrieff · This post may contain affiliate links · 9 Comments

    This is the question I've been asked to most about all the renovations & remodeling done in my 1920's home.  The previous owners ripped out the old carpet (I've heard it was moss green shag) to expose the wood floor prior to selling the house.

    Did you refinish your hardwood floors?

    Do you mean this kitchen floor that had been ripped out because the kitchen flooded?

    What you see here is mainly still wet subflooring and the original maple floor that was common to kitchens at the time.  Maple was considered a cheaper product at the time so it was used in areas guests wouldn't see.  Areas like the kitchen or the upstairs bedroom area.

    kitchen with cabinets torn out and flooring ripped out

    Below is the floor board, everyone stepped on. And I kept panicking because I thought the board would break and that someone was going to end up falling through to the basement.  I marked it so people wouldn't stand on it and it seemed to attract people!  I was always asking people to step away from that section.

    An X taped on the subflooring showing where the hole in the floor is.

    I told my contractor that as soon as I closed on the house, the absolute very first thing I wanted him to do was fix this floor!

    This was the original old wood floor (in the sunroom), with scratches, a ton of water damage, and some residual glue from the moss green shag rug that apparently covered these floors for decades.

    I was thankful that the original carpets had already been removed.  But, the required repairs were way above what I would have been able to do in a reasonable amount of time.

    waterstained floors in a sunroom

    I honestly don't think I could have seen past that carpeting.  Let that sink in - moss green shag carpet.

    But, that carpet protected this floor, in some ways.  My hundred-year-old home had floors that had never been refinished.  I was very concerned and very hopeful that the numerous patches of water-damaged hardwood floor could be refinished.  Fortunately, there weren't many deep scratches.

    closeup of waterstained floors

    There was no turning back once I owned this house!

    Sometimes I still can't believe I bought this house in the condition it was.  My life was a mess.  This house was a mess.  I guess we needed each other : ).   I did write a post at the beginning of my fixer-upper journey.  Warning!  One of my besties called me to complain that it made her cry.

    New Beginnings.  Me and my fixer-upper house.

    Refinishing Hardwood floors in my vintage home

    Refinishing the floors was the absolute last thing that was done of all the remodeling projects. It was probably the project that was the most nerve-wracking for me. I had so much hope that the floors would turn out but there were no guarantees. The floors in the WHOLE house were being refinished! Every single room, except the bathrooms which were going to be tiled, were going to be fixed, patched and a uniform new finish but on!  The different colored stain in each room was just weird.

    Choosing stain color for my vintage oak floors

    For some reason, I originally didn't realize all the floors on the main level were oak with the exception of the kitchen! I guess it's because I had once lived in a home that had that clear, shiny orangy oak colored floor. It never occurred to me that these floors that I had fallen in love with were actually oak.

    I had spoken with the wood finishing sales guy about wood stain colors. I had told him I was looking for a brown similar to what the living room looked like. Because the color was what made me not realize the floors were oak!

    a planter with colorful plants
    FREE SIGN UP

    Looking for DIY ideas for beautiful planters? You will receive lots of ideas and inspiration. Plus, tutorials on how to plant planters.

    When the floor guys came to start, they took the big orbital sander and sanded a big spot in the living room near a window.  We had good light to see the stain colors on the actual floor.  They used the applicator pad of the sander to show me the nice consistent finish I would get when they were done.

    stain samples on the oak floor

    I loved the stain on the left.  I wanted the whole floor on the main level stained the same color.  Originally, every room had a different color stain.   Below is my little front entryway to my home.   Look at the bottom of the picture to see how the stain changes from the living room to this little entryway room.

    front entryway

    See the dark stained living room floor, then the orangy stained entryway at the bottom of the above picture?  That's why I was determined to stain the whole main floor one color.  I wanted the floors to look more cohesive and not have your eye catch the line of where the stain color changed.

    What stain colors did you choose for the main floor?

    But back to my stain color.  Once I saw the stain on my floor, it was an easy decision for me. I was trying to match the period of the house, use a stain color that would look good on the whole main level, wasn't too dark and, was browner but not orange. The stain I chose is made by DuraSeal and is called Antique Brown.  Just the name sounded fitting for my vintage home!  It was an Infinity Satin finish made fy Glitsa.

    Fixing my hardwood floors - Replacing the kitchen & joining old and new flooring

    Let me show you some before and afters. Basically what the floors looked like. My kitchen originally had maple floors in it. That was because when the house built, you put the nice things in the rooms other people would see. The kitchen was hidden behind a wall. I took out that wall to open up the house. If that process is interesting to you, take a look at My Kitchen Remodel.

    This is what the kitchen originally looked like with the maple floors.

    Original kitchen with old white cabinets and maple flooring

    Unfortunately, there was a flood and I bought this house when the floor looked like the picture below.  The lower cabinets and the floors were removed to prevent mold.

    kitchen floors ripped out so the subfloor is exposed.

    I mentioned before that I wanted a uniform look with the floors throughout my house. I decided to replace the kitchen floors with oak, like the rest of the house, not with maple that had originally been in there.

    Not only did I change the floor, but I removed the wall between the kitchen and dining room.  In the picture below, you are looking from the dining room into the kitchen.  The wall in the above picture was removed.  But, focus on the floor!!  The flooring guys brought in new oak floors and the technique to join them was called 'feather them in'.   So, there is no straight line between the old floors and the new ones.  They are staggered to look like they were always joined.

    new wood feathered into old wood

    And then, this is where I just can't believe what a great job these guys did!  Everything was sanded down and refinished.  My dining room has 100-year-old floors.  My kitchen has brand new floors.  I just showed you how they were feathered together.

    view through my new kitchen to my vintage dining room.

    Huh, that would be Raji, my cat photobombing my picture on the rug in the dining room!  He's a stinker but I love him!

    Every day when I walk into my kitchen, I'm overjoyed.  It turned out so well!  There's a slideshow in my post showing how the original kitchen was taken down to the studs, the walls were removed and it was built up.   If you want to see it, the post is I bought a house without a kitchen.

    Let me just remind you how my original sunroom floors looked like.

    water damaged floors in sunroom.

    When they sanded the floors, they looked like brand new floors were installed.  All the dirt and grime, and the old finish was removed.  There were a handful of the carpet nails / tacks on the outside of the room but my floor folks took care of them.

    sanded floors in my sunroom waiting to be stained.

    So this is just my main floor!   My upstairs floors were also fixed and refinished!

    The upstairs floor.

    These upstairs bedroom floors were the epitome of orangy scratched and worn.  All the upstairs was thin maple, no wide plank flooring in this house!

    Old maple floors in damaged condition with water stains, scratches and stain worn off.

    Did you notice this pine does not have any knots?  It's

    I actually took the smaller two bedrooms and took out a wall upstairs to make a master suite.

    Floors with gaps where the walls were removed

    On the floor, in the above picture, you can see where the walls used to be.  Oh, and if you are wondering what you are looking into, that's a little attic off of my new master bedroom.  Unfortunately, it's only about 4 feet high at its highest section.

    closeup of a patch in the floor using 100 year old

    My bedroom floors were also patched with some maple that we had saved.

    What stain colors did you choose for the upstairs floor?

    Choosing the stain color upstairs was a similar process to downstairs. I had already narrowed down that I didn't want the wood to be stained clear, I wanted them to be a very light color. And, I didn't want it to be orange.

    A sample area was sanded and then stained with the color we thought was what I wanted.

    maple floor with sample spot of new stain.

    My maple floors were stained in DuraSeal nutmeg and I used the satin finish (I think it was a polyurethane finish on top) as I did on the main level.

    closeup of beautifully refinished vintage maple flooring.

    After about a year, here is the same floor area as the top two pictures (just in a different direction).

    In real life, the floor is lighter, but I've never been able to capture the color perfectly with my camera. I'm thinking it's a lighting issue since there is no natural light right there.

    Was refinishing the floors dusty?

    Is the dustless sanding really dustless?

    I've been asked about dust from sanding my floors more times than I can count. You can pay extra for dustless sanding. Which is essentially done by using equipment that collects the dust in a bad (kind of like your little sanders). It was phenomenal! I don't anyone will guarantee that their sanding system is 100% dust-free, but, this was certainly as close as you can get. I didn't have dust! None in the air, on the floor, or anywhere else. I wasn't expecting that and it was such a bonus!! If you have a dustless sanding available to you, don't hesitate - sign up for that!!

    This is what the floors looked like seconds after sanding. No dust on the floors!  I'll have to admit they did have to broom sweep and vacuum corners but overall, there was surprisingly little dust or debris of any kind anywhere!

    stripped floors, freshly sanded awaiting stain.

    I was thrilled at how clean the whole stripping and sanding process was!  The floors and everything else in my house were dust-free after this process!   I'm not sure if that will be everyone's experience but I was amazed!

    REFINISHING MY 100 YEAR OLD FLOORS

    Thanks for visiting and letting me share how my flooring update happened in my 100-year-old house.  Please take a look at more articles in this series.

    More renovation | remodeling posts!

    I had knob and tube wiring.  I updated the wiring in my whole house!
    Updating knob and tube wiring in my 100 year old house.

    You saw some of the renovations done in my kitchen.  See the details of going down to the studs and then rebuilding my kitchen.
    I bought a house without a kitchen - come see the renovations!

    This 100 year old house has picture rails in almost every room!  Here's what they are.
    Picture rails - what they are and how to use them

    Small bathroom gut and remodel.  It's small but functional and so darn cute!
    My 5 x 8 hall bath remodel

    Why I bought this fixer-upper (in the state that it was).
    New Beginnings: Me and my fixer-upper

    More my-1923-house

    • Picture rail molding
    • Knob and tube wiring
    • Increasing the humidity in a dry house.
    • My old home locks - skeleton keys, mortise locks & doorknobs.
    328 shares
    • Share2
    • Tweet

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      Recipe Rating




      This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    1. Mia Tenille

      February 20, 2020 at 2:03 pm

      Wow, that 1920's house was most certainly a project! But you saw its potential and it turned out lovely! So sad about the flooding in the kitchen but I loved what you did with it. I recently refinished my hardwood floors in my Cherry Hill NJ vacation home and was seriously SO pleased with the results! We actually live full time in New Jersey and had another company refinish our hardwood floors in our main home in Succasunna NJ and both companies did a beautiful job with it!

      Reply
    2. Margot

      February 10, 2020 at 10:53 pm

      Your floors are beautiful and may inspire me to refinish mine. Mine are about 13 years old and are starting to show wear in some areas. This combined with the fact that my floors are orange (red oak simply finished With polyurethane but I swear they have gotten more orange over the years!). I would love if they could be more the color of your main level floors!

      Reply
      • momcrieff

        February 11, 2020 at 7:04 pm

        Thanks Margot, for your comments about my floors. I was so glad I was able to get them all done before I moved in. And I do love the darker oak color!

        Reply
    3. Deana Landers

      February 10, 2020 at 10:23 am

      What a great job! I helped my brother redo his 100 year old floors an I appreciate the work you have done.

      Reply
      • momcrieff

        February 11, 2020 at 7:05 pm

        There is nothing like the character of a 100 year old house. It's a lot of work to renovate but so very worth it!

        Reply
    4. Deana Landers

      February 10, 2020 at 8:38 am

      I love your statement of how you needed each other.floor! "Sometimes I still can’t believe I bought this house in the condition it was. My life was a mess. This house was a mess. I guess we needed each other : )"

      You did a great job and it looks wonderful especially with the cat:)

      Reply
      • momcrieff

        February 11, 2020 at 7:07 pm

        My life was a mess but I'm happy and at peace now - hanging out with my buddy the cat : ).

        Reply
    5. Patti

      February 09, 2020 at 11:44 am

      Wow that's a huge project but so worth it. We've been in our home for 16 years now. Most of the hardwood looked like it was recently refinished when we bought the house. I'm always wondering if it would be a good idea to somehow refresh them. Probably when we are ready to sell which may be sooner than rather than later. Thanks for sharing your journey Susan.

      Reply
      • momcrieff

        February 11, 2020 at 7:09 pm

        Hey Patti!
        I was told that yes, you should indeed have the floor people come out every few years to refresh the hardwood finish on the floors. I don't remember the technical term, but 'refresh' is perfect in my mind : ).

        Reply

    Primary Sidebar

    I'm Susan Moncrieff! I love sharing easy recipes, especially those that take less than 30 minutes and have less than 5 ingredients. I'm passionate about gardening and creating flower planters. My home is 100 years old and sometimes you will see it in my posts! It was a true fixer upper and I love it!

    More about me →

    Subscribe to Momcrieff

    Trending Articles...

    • Peanut Butter Cookies - 3 Ingredients
    • Raised Garden Beds
    • 2 Ingredient Pumpkin Muffins
    • Knob and tube wiring
    • Shortbread cookies
    • How to plant flower pots
    • Banana chocolate muffins - 3 ingredients.
    • Three Ingredient Peach Cobbler

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About

    • About Susan Moncrieff
    • Advertising and Disclosures
    • Contact

    Categories

    • My 100 year old home
    • Easy Recipes
    • Gardening
    • DIY
    • Misc

    Most Popular

    • 25 Outdoor Planters
    • My Raised Garden Beds
    • My white kitchen remodel 
    • Knob and tube wiring
    • Three Ingredient Peach Cobbler
    • Deconstructed cabbage rolls

    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

    Copyright © 2023

    © Copyright 2020 Momcrieff · All Rights Reserved ·

    328 shares
    • 2